Children should be given a truthful
account of the brutality of war, not a
“marketised fiction”, teachers said
yesterday, as they voted to oppose
military recruitment campaigns in
schools based on government
“propaganda”.
Members of the National Union of
Teachers accused the Ministry of Defence
of focusing on vulnerable teenagers from
deprived backgrounds through
“misleading” information that glamorised
war.
The MoD replied that it was invited
into 1,000 schools a year, and that this
was to raise awareness of the role of
the Armed Forces, not to recruit.
Delegates at the NUT annual
conference were told that material about
the military distributed in schools did
not always allow informed choices. They
called for peace campaigners or those
who had experienced the horror of war to
be invited into schools alongside
military representatives.
Paul McGarr, a delegate from East
London, said that the union did not
want to undermine servicemen and women
but that the Forces were turning to
schools to fill a recruitment
shortage.
Mr McGarr said: “Let’s just try and
imagine what recruitment material
would have to say were it not to be
misleading. We would have material
saying, ‘Join the Army and we will
send you to carry out the imperialist
occupation of other people’s
countries. Join the Army and we will
send you to bomb, shoot and possibly
torture fellow human beings.
“Join the Army and we will send you
probably poorly equipped into
situations where people will try to
shoot or kill you because you are
occupying other people’s countries.
Join the Army, and if you come home,
possibly injured or mentally damaged,
you and your family will be shabbily
treated.”
David Clinch, a teacher from Devon
who joined the Royal Navy in 1967 on
leaving school, where he had been a
cadet, said that military cadet forces
should be barred from schools because
they were used for recruitment.
Martin Reed, of the NUT executive,
said that teachers were by law
required to treat political issues in
a balanced way and to avoid partisan
views. “It should be absolutely clear
that the reality of war is
demonstrated, not the marketised
fiction of war,” he said.
Steve Sinnott, the union’s general
secretary, has already written to Ed
Balls, the Schools Secretary, to
complain about a lesson plan produced
for the MoD by an organisation called
Kids Connections that, Mr Sinnott
said, focused on “the ongoing
occupation of Iraq by British Armed
Forces”. A worksheet emphasised the
Forces’ reconstruction work but, Mr
Sinnott alleged, did not mention
civilian casualties.
This year a Joseph Rowntree Trust
report suggested that the Army was
seeking to attract recruits by
glamorising warfare and underplaying
the risks involved in a military
career.
Yesterday delegates at the union’s
conference in Manchester voted in
favour of a motion opposing military
recruitment activities “based upon
misleading propaganda”. The motion
defended the rights of teachers “not
to take part in activities promoting
military recruitment, or which they
feel present a partisan view of war
and life in the military”. It said
that young people should be able to
“hear a speaker promoting alternative
points of view” and to have “education
for peace embedded in the curriculum
along with education about the
military”.
Mr Sinnott said he would convene a
meeting of all parties involved, with
a view to drawing up a protocol on
recruitment. “I see nothing wrong in
explaining to youngsters what life is
like in the military, but you have to
tell them the whole truth,” he said.
A spokesman for the MoD said that
its recruitment practices avoided
glamorising war and propaganda, adding
that the Armed Forces did not recruit
in schools and did not seek to attract
youngsters aged under 16.
The Defence Dynamics initiative was
not a recruitment activity, he said.
The school material criticised by the
NUT was part of a proposed English
course on creative writing that
included two articles, one positive
about the Iraq conflict and the other
critical.
“A career in the Armed Forces is
not something to be ashamed of and we
are proud to raise awareness of the
tremendous work that our Service
personnel do,” he said.